PickFlick
The Curious Case of Natalia Grace

The Curious Case of Natalia Grace

TV-142023•43m•7.7/10
CrimeDocumentary

Ratings

🎬TMDb
7.7/10(51)

This stranger-than-fiction series explores the question of whether Natalia Barnett is an exploited Ukrainian child with dwarfism or a dangerous adult masquerading as a child. Featuring exclusive bombshell interviews with members of Natalia's adoptive family, relatives, friends, legal experts, and neighbors, this docuseries offers a never-before-seen glimpse into the Barnett family, Natalia's identity, Michael Barnett's October 2022 trial, as well as key insights into new theories and evidence.

Open in PickFlick

Production

Hot Snakes Media

Language

EN

Status

Ended

First Aired

May 29, 2023

Last Aired

January 7, 2025

Networks

Investigation Discovery

Trailers & Videos

Where to Watch
Region US · Lang EN
US
No providers available for this region.
Seasons & Episodes
Select a season to view episodes. Reddit links may contain spoilers.
Season
Meet the Barnetts
E1
Meet the Barnetts
Air date: 2023-05-29
The Barnett’s adoption of Natalia, an allegedly six-year-old Ukrainian Orphan, turns into a nightmare when they learn she may not be six or Ukrainian. With suspicions mounting, the Barnetts discover they may have an adult stranger in their home.
Orphan or Imposter?
E2
Orphan or Imposter?
Air date: 2023-05-29
Michael Barnett reveals Natalia tried to poison and harm them as the Barnett’s own lies surface. This information leads to the question -- is there more than one villain here?
Nightmare Neighbor
E3
Nightmare Neighbor
Air date: 2023-05-30
Now re-aged as an adult and living alone, Natalia wreaks havoc at her new apartment by sexually propositioning and stalking the residents. Meanwhile, the Barnett’s truly sinister side emerges as they face a social services investigation into Natalia.
Victim or Villain?
E4
Victim or Villain?
Air date: 2023-05-31
The Barnetts abandon Natalia in an apartment in Lafayette, Indiana. With no food, a/c, electricity or phone, the police get involved. Despite Michael’s efforts to blame Kristine solely, his shocking confessions lead to their arrests.
Barnett vs. Barnett
E5
Barnett vs. Barnett
Air date: 2023-05-31
As Michael’s trial approaches, he shifts fault to Kristine and catches a break when the judge throws out any discussion of Natalia’s age during the trial.
Punch Or Be Punched
E6
Punch Or Be Punched
Air date: 2023-06-01
Michael Barnett must face the consequences of his actions, and Kristine is next.

Cast

Nicole DePaul

Self

Mackenzie DePaul

Self - Nicole's Daughter

Recommended

Paranormal Survivor

Paranormal Survivor

7.9
2015
TV Show

A chilling series in which survivors of a paranormal experience relive their harrowing encounter.

Paranormal Survivor

2015
7.9
Disasters at Sea

Disasters at Sea

7.1
2018
TV Show

Dedicated investigators uncover the devastating chain of circumstances that caused a maritime disaster. With the evidence at the bottom of the sea, ingenuity is required to find the cause – whether it is human error or the uncontrollable ocean.

Disasters at Sea

2018
7.1
Ridley

Ridley

6.1
2022
TV Show

Retired Detective Inspector Alex Ridley is lured back into service as a consultant detective when his former protégée, Carol Farman, needs help cracking a complex murder case.

Ridley

2022
6.1
Taken Together: Who Killed Lyric and Elizabeth?

Taken Together: Who Killed Lyric and Elizabeth?

6.2
2024
TV Show

Dives into the haunting 2012 double abduction of two cousins, 10-year-old Lyric Cook-Morrissey and 8-year-old Elizabeth Collins, in Evansdale, Iowa. With over seven years of exclusive access and insider interviews.

Taken Together: Who Killed Lyric and Elizabeth?

2024
6.2
The Pitt

The Pitt

8.7
2025
TV Show

The staff of Pittsburgh's Trauma Medical Center work around the clock to save lives in an overcrowded and underfunded emergency department.

The Pitt

2025
8.7
The 8 Show

The 8 Show

7.2
2024
TV Show

Eight individuals trapped in a mysterious 8-story building participate in a tempting but dangerous show where they earn money as time passes.

The 8 Show

2024
7.2
Lioness

Lioness

8.0
2023
TV Show

Cruz Manuelos, a rough-around-the-edges but passionate young Marine, is recruited to join the CIA's Lioness Engagement Team to help bring down a terrorist organization from within. Joe, the station chief of the Lioness program, is tasked with training, managing and leading her female undercover operatives.

Lioness

2023
8.0
Fargo

Fargo

8.3
2014
TV Show

A close-knit anthology series dealing with stories involving malice, violence and murder based in and around Minnesota.

Fargo

2014
8.3
Silo

Silo

8.1
2023
TV Show

In a ruined and toxic future, thousands live in a giant silo deep underground. After its sheriff breaks a cardinal rule and residents die mysteriously, engineer Juliette starts to uncover shocking secrets and the truth about the silo.

Silo

2023
8.1
Modern Family

Modern Family

7.9
2009
TV Show

The Pritchett-Dunphy-Tucker clan is a wonderfully large and blended family. They give us an honest and often hilarious look into the sometimes warm, sometimes twisted, embrace of the modern family.

Modern Family

2009
7.9
FROM

FROM

8.2
2022
TV Show

Unravel the mystery of a nightmarish town in middle America that traps all those who enter. As the unwilling residents fight to keep a sense of normalcy and search for a way out, they must also survive the threats of the surrounding forest – including the terrifying creatures that come out when the sun goes down.

FROM

2022
8.2
The Last of Us

The Last of Us

8.4
2023
TV Show

Twenty years after modern civilization has been destroyed, Joel, a hardened survivor, is hired to smuggle Ellie, a 14-year-old girl, out of an oppressive quarantine zone. What starts as a small job soon becomes a brutal, heartbreaking journey, as they both must traverse the United States and depend on each other for survival.

The Last of Us

2023
8.4

Similar TV Shows

Tell Me What You Saw

Tell Me What You Saw

7.4
2020
TV Show

The eccentric Oh Hyun Jae was a peerless criminal profiler until a bomb planted by a serial killer took the life of his young fiancée, causing him to become a recluse. When a serial killer long thought dead returns to terrorize the city, rising star of the police, Hwang Hwa Young, resolves to outwit the killer. To do so, she teams up with both Oh and the remarkable rookie cop Cha Soo Young, whose photographic memory may prove to be a powerful crime-fighting weapon.

Tell Me What You Saw

2020
7.4
Giver Taker

Giver Taker

8.0
2023
TV Show

Former elementary school teacher and detective, Kurasawa Itsuki (Nakatani Miki), has a history with Kishi Ruoto (Kikuchi Fuma). At the age of 12 and her 6th grade student, Kishi murdered Kurasawa's daughter. The young age of the murderer caused the bizarre murder case to send shockwaves throughout Japan. Kurasawa experienced despair and quit her job as a teacher to become a detective with the desire of "saving as many people as possible from suffering like I did". Driven by her strong conviction, Kurasawa spends 12 years working hard to solve cases before learning that Kishi is to be discharged from a medical reformatory just before the anniversary of her daughter's death. One day, she receives a text message from the supposedly "completely rehabilitated" Kishi promising to "take away your precious things once again". This was the beginning of a new incident that would shock all of Japan again.

Giver Taker

2023
8.0
Thriller

Thriller

6.6
1973
TV Show

Thriller is a British television series, originally broadcast in the UK from 1973 to 1976. It is an anthology series: each episode has a self-contained story and its own cast. As the title suggests, each story is a thriller of some variety, from tales of the supernatural to down-to-earth whodunits.

Thriller

1973
6.6
Suspects

Suspects

5.4
2014
TV Show

Set in London, each episode is a self-contained story, starting with a news report, then following the team of three detectives as they investigate the circumstances the crime. The cases themselves are hard-hitting with contemporary themes, such as the search for a soldier with PTSD, a murder that has been made to look like an assisted suicide and the gang rape of a young teenager.

Suspects

2014
5.4
Grantchester

Grantchester

7.3
2014
TV Show

In 1953 at the hamlet of Grantchester, Sidney Chambers—a charismatic, charming clergyman—turns investigative vicar when one of his parishioners dies in suspicious circumstances.

Grantchester

2014
7.3
Secrets, Lies, and DNA Ties

Secrets, Lies, and DNA Ties

2023
TV Show

When questions about familial genealogy arise, it's up to two diligent and sophisticated owners of the company DNA Confidential to unearth the Secrets, Lies and DNA Ties among their clients in order to get the answers needed.

Secrets, Lies, and DNA Ties

2023
Sleeping With Death

Sleeping With Death

7.0
2022
TV Show

This compelling edge-of-your-seat docu-series recounts some of the most bizarre and crazy murders in which someone wakes up to a dead body.. With access to lead investigators, key witnesses and those closest to the victim, the series uncovers the secrets and truth behind each twisted murder.

Sleeping With Death

2022
7.0
Dateline

Dateline

6.4
1992
TV Show

Dateline NBC, or simply Dateline, is a weekly American television newsmagazine series. It was previously the network's flagship newsmagazine, but now focuses mainly on true crime stories with only occasional editions that focus on other topics.

Dateline

1992
6.4
Captured Hospital

Captured Hospital

7.0
2023
TV Show

The story is set in a big hospital which is infiltrated and taken over by an armed group wearing devil masks. Musashi Saburo a police officer on leave of absence has to save the hostages within a set time limit.

Captured Hospital

2023
7.0
Father Dowling Mysteries

Father Dowling Mysteries

7.4
1989
TV Show

Father Dowling is a sleuthing parish priest from Chicago who investigates baffling crimes

Father Dowling Mysteries

1989
7.4
Detective Conan

Detective Conan

8.0
1996
TV Show

The son of a world famous mystery writer, Jimmy Kudo, has achieved his own notoriety by assisting the local police as a student detective. He has always been able to solve the most difficult of criminal cases using his wits and power of reason.

Detective Conan

1996
8.0
Nobody Knows

Nobody Knows

8.1
2020
TV Show

A high school boy falls off of the top of a building and lapses into a coma. A detective and his school teacher attempt to get to the bottom of the incident.

Nobody Knows

2020
8.1